Posts Tagged ‘John Zogby’

The American Dream, Part 2 — What is it?

Monday, February 23rd, 2009

In a world where Wall Streeters get billions in bonuses without regard to performance, a presidential candidate can’t even remember how many homes he owns, and a baseball player gets a quarter of a billion dollar contract, what is The American Dream? Is it the potential to become obscenely wealthy?

“Lacking a hereditary upper class, [and channeling Vanderbilt, Rockefeller, and Carnegie], Americans have typically looked in the mirror and asked, Why not me?” says Jerry Adler in “Why There Won’t Be a Revolution.” http://www.newsweek.com/id/183718

But, often you hear The American Dream associated simply with the opportunity to own one’s own home. Is that simple but profound dream The Real One?

John Zogby, the pollster, has written a book called The Way We’ll Be: The Zogby Report on the Transformation of the American Dream. Oddly enough, Mr. Zogby spends no time either identifying what The American Dream is, or how it has been, or will be transformed. Still, The Way We’ll Be has a lot of tidbits about our attitudes.

Zogby International has asked the following question of Americans for the past ten or so years:

Which best represents your life goals:

(A) I believe the American Dream means material success. It is possible for me, my family, and most middle class Americans to achieve.

(B) I believe that you can achieve the American Dream through spiritual fulfillment rather than material success.

(C) I believe the American Dream means material success. It exists but is more likely to be achieved by my children and not by me.

(D) I believe I cannot achieve the American Dream whether material or spiritual. Nor can most middle class Americans.

Zogby calls those who answer (C) “deferred dreamers” and those who answer (D) are the “dreamless dead.” (C) and (D) combined consistently represent 15% to 21% of respondents.

36% answer (A). 36% for (B), too, whom Zogby calls the “secular spiritualists.”

But isn’t something missing? Aren’t there more vectors at work than “material” and “spiritual”?

What became of “Life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness”? These cover more than materiality and spirituality; these cover opportunity, security in one’s home and pursuits, and individuality in electing what to pursue.

Maybe we have to look back to the Declaration of Independence to find what The American Dream was and, so, what it has become.

Next time.

The ER Blog Is Back! Chasing The American Dream, Part 1

Monday, February 2nd, 2009

I’ve been thinking about the concept of The American Dream for a long time — where it fits into our lives and where it should fit.

Lately things are driving me to write down some bones about it. The election of our new President. The currency of MLK’s Dream. The New American Melting Pot –  a palpably biological phenomenon. The Madoff and Blagojevich greed. The meltdown of our economy. The rise of Green. And amidst the turmoil, all the questions about how we should live — saving more, carrying less credit burden, buying less, buying local, being responsible.

So what exactly is The American Dream? How has it morphed over the years? And should we remake it?

Until the Great Recession, The American Dream seemed synonymous with Bling, McMansions, and  do-it-if-you-can-get-away-with-it. Disposable everything. Convenience, indulgence and soft comfort elevated to the highest values.

Has it always been that way? Wasn’t there a pastoral/bucolic day-gone-by where Life, Liberty and The Pursuit of Happiness meant simple physical, political and religious security joined with opportunity? I always assumed so.  Then I heard a reference to Democracy in America, attributing to its author, Alexis de Tocqueville, the observation that even back in the early Nineteenth Century, Americans were striving to accumulate things only to lose interest upon their attainment, eye always on the next acquisition. Maybe my vision of American values has been as mythological as George Washington’s I-cannot-tell-a-lie cherry tree.

These questions swirl around ElegantRoots.com since we sell quality gifts from around the world — eco-friendly and socially responsible, yes. Soulful, artisan-made, yes. Buy-less-but-buy-better things, yes. But still things. Green bling? What place for things in a New American Dream?

I’m taking input from heavy-weights the likes of John Zogby from The Way We’ll Be, Messr. de Tocqueville, Andrew J. Bacevich from The Limits of Power, Fareed Zacaria from The Post-American World, Thomas Friedman from Hot, Flat and Crowded, and who knows who else. Write to me — maybe I’ll be quoting you.

Til Next Time,

Rob Favole

Elegant Roots